York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates

Name: York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates
Brand: York Barbell
Rating: 4.98 (29 reviews)

York Barbell’s Legacy plates are a modern, precision-milled reissue of the company’s original “milled-era” Olympic Standard plates – the same design that built York’s reputation in the mid-20th century. Each plate is milled on the back and edge for a smooth, deep-dish profile (rather than the raised lip of typical cast iron), which both makes them easier to grip one-handed and calibrates weight to within +/-2% of the marked value. They’re cast iron, sold individually, and available across the full range a lifter needs: 2.5, 5, and 10 lb change plates up through 25, 35, 45, and 100 lb full-size plates, all sized for a standard 2” Olympic bar sleeve.

Buying guide

Best Weight Plates for Your Home Gym — July 2026 Bumper Plates or Iron Plates? How to Pick Your First Set — July 2026 Do You Need Calibrated or Competition Plates? — July 2026 How Much Do Weight Plates Cost Per Pound? — July 2026 What Weight Set Should a Beginner Buy? — July 2026 Will Dropping Weights Damage Your Floor? — July 2026

5 lb	7.5" diameter x 3/4" thick
10 lb	9.125" diameter x 1" thick
25 lb	12" diameter x 1.25" thick
35 lb	14.875" diameter x 1.375" thick
45 lb	17.5" diameter x 1.5" thick
2.5 lb	6.5" diameter x 7/16" thick
Finish	Milled back and edge (smooth, deep-dish profile)
Sold as	Individually
Material	Cast iron
Bore diameter	2" (standard Olympic)
Weight tolerance	+/-2% of indicated weight
Available weights	2.5, 5, 10, 25, 35, 45, 100 lb

What is a Weight Plate?

What weight plates are

Weight plates load your barbell — but “plate” covers two very different tools. Bumper plates are rubber discs around a steel hub, all the same ~450mm diameter, built to be dropped from overhead without damaging your floor or bar; they’re the default for Olympic lifting and CrossFit. Iron/steel plates are denser and thinner per pound, cheaper, and quieter to load, but most aren’t made to be dropped — better for slow, controlled powerlifting-style work.

What actually matters

Bumper vs. iron. Buy bumpers if the bar might hit the floor; iron (or rubber-coated iron) for controlled lifts and compact loading.
Weight tolerance. How far a plate strays from its stated weight (±1% is tight, ±3% loose). It barely matters for general training but adds up if you chase a specific total — which is why serious lifters add small change / fractional plates.
Collar fit & bounce. The center hole should fit your bar’s sleeve snugly; rubber durometer (around 88 Shore A) controls how “dead” a dropped plate lands.
Coating & set composition. Virgin rubber holds up and smells less than recycled crumb rubber; plan a starting set (usually a pair each of 45/25/10/5 lb plus change plates) around the lifts you actually do.

Who it’s for

Every barbell gym needs plates. Most home lifters should start with a bumper set, then add iron, change, or specialty plates as a second purchase once they know what their training is missing.

How it compares

	York Barbell Milled Vintage Weight Plates	Micro Gainz Multi-Color Olympic Size Fractional Weight Plates Set	Atlas Barbell Vintage Weight Plates	4SPORT Olympic Fractional Plates
GymRadar rating	4.98/5	5.0/5	5.0/5	5.0/5
Price	$67.28	$44.99		$31.94
5 lb	7.5" diameter x 3/4" thick
10 lb	9.125" diameter x 1" thick
25 lb	12" diameter x 1.25" thick
35 lb	14.875" diameter x 1.375" thick
45 lb	17.5" diameter x 1.5" thick
2.5 lb	6.5" diameter x 7/16" thick
Finish	Milled back and edge (smooth, deep-dish profile)	Multi-color powder coat, color-coded by weight		Machined, stainless-steel-colored plates
Sold as	Individually
Material	Cast iron	Sintered metal	Cast iron	Alloy steel
Bore diameter	2" (standard Olympic)
Weight tolerance	+/-2% of indicated weight
Available weights	2.5, 5, 10, 25, 35, 45, 100 lb		1.25 lb change plates up through 45 lb plates

5.0/5 · 29 GymRadar reviews

Reviews by source

Expert	4.98/5	29 reviews
Youtube	4.5/5	1 reviews
Reddit	4.3/5	2 reviews

York’s milled plates – both the vintage originals and the modern “Legacy” reissue that replicates them – earn consistent praise for doing the fundamentals right: a milled back and edge for a smoother, more solid feel than raw cast iron, and weight that lands dead-on or within a few hundredths of a pound of the mark, well inside the advertised +/-2% tolerance. YouTube reviewer Gluck’s Gym and two r/homegym threads all independently confirm accurate scaling and rate the milling quality above typical budget cast iron. The standout dimension is build quality/accuracy; the weakest is value consistency and provenance – small change plates (2.5/5/10 lb) are all priced identically regardless of weight, and some buyers flag that the current Legacy reissue is made in China, a step away from the American-made vintage plates it’s styled after. Garage Gym Reviews’ listing and the Garage Gym Experiment retrospective add useful historical context but no independent testing verdict of their own.

+Build quality: milled back and edge give a noticeably smoother, more solid feel than raw cast iron plates (Gluck's Gym, r/homegym)
+Functionality: scales dead-on or within a few hundredths of a pound of the marked weight, well inside the advertised +/-2% tolerance (Gluck's Gym, r/homegym "York Legacy Plates" thread)
+Durability: cast iron construction and a heritage design that owners of the original vintage plates report still using decades later (r/homegym "New to me plates" thread)
+Versatility: standard 2" Olympic bore and a wide weight range (2.5 to 100 lb) covers everything from micro-loading to max-effort plates (yorkbarbell.com)
+Value: sale pricing on larger plates works out to roughly $1.50-$1.70/lb, in line with what buyers consider fair for milled quality (yorkbarbell.com, Garage Gym Experiment)

−Value: the 2.5, 5, and 10 lb change plates are all priced identically ($4.23 each) regardless of actual weight (yorkbarbell.com)
−Build quality: paint finish is a recurring minor complaint -- functional but described as unremarkable (r/homegym "York Legacy Plates" thread)
−Durability: the modern Legacy reissue is reportedly made in China, a departure from the American-made vintage originals it's modeled on, which some buyers weigh as a heritage/quality concern (r/homegym)
−Functionality: individual plates can still deviate slightly within tolerance (one reviewer measured 44.0-45.6 lb across ten 45 lb plates) (r/homegym "York Legacy Plates" thread)
−Build quality: no in-depth third-party lab testing found -- coverage leans on unboxing/impressions video and forum reports rather than a rigorous editorial review (Garage Gym Reviews)

$67.28

Buy Now